The cartridge dust collector and bag house dust collector,which one is better ?

Cartridge Dust Collectors and Bag House Dust Collectors are widely used in the field of industrial dust removal.
The dust removal principle is the same, and the only difference is the dust removal medium. It is difficult to say which of the two dust collectors is better. It is like steamed buns and rice. It doesn't matter whether it is good or bad. As long as the design is reasonable and the conditions permit, it can achieve a good dust removal effect.

 

However, cartridge dust collectors and baghouse dust collectors still have their own characteristics in some specific fields and application environments. Let's share them briefly below.

 

Advantages of bag house dust collector,

 

1: The service life of the filter bag should be relatively longer and not easy to break;

 

2: The filter bag has a good cleaning effect and can clean the dust completely;

 

3: The subsequent long-term use and maintenance costs are low;

 

4: High filtration efficiency

 

Disadvantages of bag house dust collector,

 

1: The filter area of ​​the bag is small.

 

2: Because the bag area is small, the Bag Filter equipment is slightly larger, so the floor area is slightly larger; compared with the filter element type dust collector, the volume of the filter cartridge type of the same filter area is more modest.

 

3: The initial investment cost is large;

 

Advantages of the cartridge dust collector:

 

1: The initial investment cost is small;

 

2: The equipment is small and the floor area is small;

 

3: The filtering effect is no different from that of the bag, and both are widely used in the market. Filtering method.

 

Disadvantages of cartridge dust collector:

 

1: Because the surface of the filter element is V-shaped, the tip of the fold is easily damaged when the compressed air is repeatedly cleaned;

 

2: Because the V-shaped fold space is small, dust is easy to remain or accumulate in the V-shaped area and cannot be cleaned, which will block the filter element and increase the filtration resistance, thereby reducing the filtration area. The filter element is more likely to be damaged.

 

3: Because the filter element is easy to be blocked and damaged, the replacement frequency will be relatively higher.

 

4: Because the replacement frequency and the price of the filter element are higher, the subsequent maintenance cost of the cartridge dust collector will definitely be higher.

 

The above is a simple comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of the cartridge dust collector and the bag dust collector. No matter which one you choose, you must find a manufacturer with design capabilities to determine whether to use a bag or a cartridge according to the different dust properties and different usage environments.